Mr. Alexandros Glykas, Director at DYNAMARINe, discusses what can negatively affect Ship-to-Ship operations resulting in an incident and suggests best practices to strengthen safety culture during STS onboard tankers. Mr. Glykas concludes that above all, the Master holds the final responsibility for these operations as well, therefore, it is necessary for the tanker operator to have direct access to information and past experience in order to be able to assess risk factors. Also, the level of expertise of the STS service provider is of paramount importance.
The tanker industry is a highly competitive market similar to other sectors where demand of charter and offer of tonnage are part of the equation. But are safety related matters parameters of the same equation or are minimum safety requirements taken for granted for all competitors? Past incident data, involving vessels and the human element, not necessarily substandard, have resulted in more stringer regulations or inspection practices emerging either from statutory or commercial bodies.
An incident or bad practice in Ship-to-Ship does not benefit the industry. The reason is simple. Any incident may increase the burden from the stakeholder whose reputation might be highly affected. Usually such stakeholders are those who have a global operational appearance along with high quality standards. It can be a ship owner, an STS service provider, a cargo owner, a\ charterer or a trader.
The solution is sharing Ship-to-Ship best practices amongst those who comprise the final barrier in safety. Those are the Masters and their crews. In order to benefit from such knowledge sharing, they should be aided by sophisticated internal procedures, supported by the involved STS service providers, and rewarded by their charterers and cargo owners. Any prudent organisation would benefit from the sharing of knowledge in Ship-to-Ship transfers, regardless its operational size. The needed “Safety culture” fits in any organisation who would benefit from Ship-to Ship best practices.
Focusing on the human element and organisation procedures
Ship-to-Ship procedures and the human element are the major factors in the risk analysis. Procedures should consider the causal factors as presented at the latest OCMF/ICS/SIGTTO/CDI STS guidelines (2013) and Marpol chapter 8 of Annex 1. Some causal factors are directly linked to crew experience or STS service provider expertise such as:
- Inadequate crew training,
- Inadequate crew experience,
Excessive roll angles,
- Inadequate equipment inspection testing and maintenance,
- Inadequate compatibility study,
- Inadequate incident management,
- Inadequate fendering,
It is therefore necessary for the tanker operator to have direct access to information and past experience in order to be able to assess such factors. Since the Master is solely responsible for the operation, the Master is the last barrier of safety. The Master has the final responsibility and is the final frontier for safety
The level of expertise of the service provider and the POAC is of paramount importance. Currently there are about 60 organisations operating worldwide as STS service providers and not all of them have the organisational level according to all four stages of the OCIMF “Ship to Ship Service Provider Management” Self-assessment.
DYNAMARINe’s onlineSTS.net platform provides access to Ship-to-Ship best practices and disseminate those through a transparent procedure to its clients. The platform operates 24/7, it covers more than 200 identified STS locations and delivers assessment of the Ship-to-Ship elements to the Master and tanker owner for their final review.
By Alexandros Glykas, Director, DYNAMARINe
The views presented hereabove are only those of the author and not necessarily those of SAFETY4SEA and are for information sharing and discussion purposes only.
Naval Architect and Marine Engineer, motivated by the dynamism of the Maritime Industry and endless opportunities for raising the standards for a safer working environment for the seafarers and the protection of the environment. Due diligence in STS (Ship to ship transfer) Operations. STS Operations were statutory regulated by IMO MEPC 186 (59) on 2010. This resolution was a proactive initiative by the IMO since no major marine accident was attributed to an STS Operation. Such Proactive initiative by the IMO has lead Prudent Tanker Operators to adopt and become members of STS concept introduced by DYNAMARINe through it’s dedicated STS service, onlinests.net.